Can I see it?

Where to See Giambattista Pittoni: A Painted-Out Heaven and a Lost Temple

Someone once painted over God the Father in Pittoni’s Nativity. Following his pictures from London to Venice and Paris means recovering missing figures, lost commissions and even a missing name.

2. november 2026 · 7 min. læsning · ART WIKI’s redaktion

Heaven disappeared from The Nativity with God the Father and the Holy Ghost in the nineteenth century. Someone covered its upper figures with paint, leaving the family below to occupy the picture without that celestial company. Cleaning in 1959 brought them back. A pre-cleaning photograph in the Federico Zeri archive preserves the earlier appearance, when a person looking at the same canvas would have seen a different religious story.

London: Joseph sleeps through the revelation

The National Gallery’s Nativity keeps two kinds of attention in play. Joseph has fallen asleep; Mary tends a wriggling baby. Above them, the Father and the dove complete the heavenly Trinity. Below, the parents and child form its earthly counterpart. The painting’s original destination is unknown. Its nineteenth-century alterations may have made it easier to sell, although the motive is uncertain.

Begin with Joseph. His exhaustion makes a useful entry into a composition whose theology might otherwise feel remote. A sleeping adult beside a restless infant needs no explanation. Then follow the distance between the family and the upper figures. The story of the overpainting makes that distance harder to take for granted; what now looks inseparable could once be removed by a later owner’s decision.

The Nativity with God the Father and the Holy Ghost
The heavenly figures were recovered in 1959. An older photograph records the painting before cleaning. Se værket →

Venice: a gift whose assignment changed hands

Pittoni’s Annunciation, in the Gallerie dell’Accademia, began within the new Venetian academy’s obligations to itself. In November 1756 the subject was assigned to Tiepolo, while Pittoni was to paint Saint Mark. The allocation changed. A payment for canvas in March 1757 identifies Pittoni with the Annunciation, and he delivered the painting in February 1758. The academicians gave their work; the institution paid for materials.

The Annunciation was intended for the academy’s meeting room at the Fonteghetto della Farina. It subsequently appeared at the Sensa fair in 1777, ten years after Pittoni’s death. An original church setting cannot explain this history. This sacred encounter also belonged to a room where painters conducted institutional business. Its audience included colleagues who knew exactly what a painted gesture cost in decisions and revisions.

Pittoni succeeded Tiepolo as president in 1758. It is easy to overlook that position when approaching Venetian painting through the names that dominate museums today. Here the academy’s own picture provides a reason to pause over the colleague who took the chair after Tiepolo.

Annunciation
Painted for the Venetian academy in 1757 and delivered in 1758, the Annunciation belonged to its meeting room. Se værket →

Venice: the small picture outlives the large one

Another Accademia canvas, Crassus Sacks the Temple of Jerusalem, survived a commission whose finished painting is lost. Francesco Algarotti chose Pittoni in 1743 to supply a picture for Augustus III’s gallery in Dresden. The Venetian painting is its model. In it, soldiers open a chest while sacred vessels are gathered into cloth. A gold beam offered to save the temple’s treasure has failed to stop the plunder.

The violence operates through objects being handled. Follow the chest and the vessels before trying to identify everyone in the crowd. A theft on this scale requires carrying, wrapping and moving; the painting allows those ordinary actions to sit beside the confrontation. The little canvas has become the surviving witness to a much larger undertaking.

Small compositions had a market of their own. Pittoni’s workshop repeated successful subjects, and finished versions of his preparatory designs could become collector’s pictures. That helps explain why a model deserved to be kept. It could leave the practical business of a commission behind and lead a second life in a cabinet.

Paris: two captives, opposite decisions

The Louvre’s Continence of Scipio and Polyxena before the Tomb of Achilles form a pair. Their shared subject is a victor’s power over a captive. In Livy’s account, Scipio returns a young woman to her betrothed and refuses her family’s ransom. Polyxena’s story takes the other direction: the dead Achilles demands the Trojan princess as a sacrifice.

Ovid gives Polyxena resistance even in defeat. She would rather die than live enslaved. Set that beside Scipio’s decision and the pair becomes uncomfortable to read as polite classical decoration. One ruler can relinquish possession of a person; another claim reaches beyond the grave. The captives make the choices of the powerful visible.

Both paintings entered the public museum in 1793, having been recorded in 1791 under Sebastiano Ricci’s name. Christ Giving the Keys to Paradise to Saint Peter shared that misattribution. An article published in 1912 discussed returning these Louvre pictures to Pittoni. His recovery involved finding his paintings inside other painters’ reputations.

For a trip, start by checking the two Venetian pictures or the London Nativity directly with their museums. The three Louvre paintings discussed here were not on view on our autumn 2026 check. Paris therefore needs a specific enquiry before you build an afternoon around Pittoni; a collection’s ownership alone will not get you in front of its pictures.

På forsiden: Annunciation — Dzhovanni Battista Pittoni. Didier Descouens · Public domain · Wikimedia Commons